In Specters of Marx, written almost 30 years later than “Violence and Metaphysics,” Derrida famously invokes and sketches what he calls hauntology, namely, a “logic of haunting” understood as a discourse and practice that would transcend “the opposition between presence and non‐presence, actuality and inactuality, life and non‐life”. eBook Published 18 May 2001 . Scribd is the world's largest social reading and publishing site. While Derrida woul… Whereas Levinas sees written communication as dead … As has been long understood, Levinas’s 1974 Otherwise Than Being can be seen in part as a response to Derrida’s criticism in the 1964 essay “Violence and Metaphysics.” At the same time Derrida’s understanding of the “trace” was shaped by his reading of Levinas’s use of the same term in his 1963 essay, “The Trace of the Other.” First Published 1982 . pp. The chapter concludes with a reflection on violence that seeks to avoid both of the extremes that claim violence to be either (A) senseless and irrational or (B) a determinable product of an undergirding cause-effect structure. Violence and Historicity: Derrida’s Early Readings of Heidegger. Derrida’s notion that justice is never fully present, and is different from itself, harkens back to his critique of the metaphysics of presence and to his notion of différance. He was also born into an environment of some discrimination. Derrida, J. Every man will be forced to recognize his neighbor. But he challenges the idea that only face-to-face interaction can be ethical. Subjects Humanities. The article suggests that, in the process of Derrida reading Levinas, the radical alterity of the other is sustained in ‘Violence and Metaphysics’ principally in terms of the legitimacy (or ‘discipline’) of a question that arises only on the hither side of a phenomenology of the other – a phenomenology that emerges, nonetheless, as its unacknowledged ground. Over 10 million scientific documents at your fingertips. In, Derrida, J. … The former often abandons hope to describe violence’s intelligibility; the latter tends to operate with a blind optimism that violence is reasonable and therefore can be eradicated once we determine its meaning. On Violence, Justic e and Deconstruction Chung-Hsiung Lai National Cheng Kung University Abstract In this paper, I will first explore the chiasmus relation between violence and metaphysics in the thought of Levinas1 and Derrida. In J. Caputo (Ed.). In T. Dutoit (Ed.). A. The very nature of In. Nass, M. (2015a). Derrida mentions Levinas’s ‘La Trace de l’autre’ in ‘Violence and Metaphysics’, in Writing and Difference, trans., with an introduction and additional notes, by Alan Bass (London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1978), pp. In H. G. Coward & T. Foshay (Eds.). This chapter interprets Derrida’s understanding of religion and violence in his 1998 “Faith and Knowledge” through his critique of “meaning” in his 1967 “Violence and Metaphysics.” This is done in order to arrive at a deeper, yet often overlooked observation—that “meaning” (attempting to bring to light and expose a single point of origination) and “signification” (as a process void of difference and bound to presence) themselves are in many cases the bases of the violence of metaphysics. Abstract. More Metaphysical Than Metaphysics: An Investigation of "Violence and Metaphysics" The Test of the Sign: An Investigation of Voice and Phenomenon Part Four: The Turn in Derrida Looking for Noon at Two O'Clock: An Investigation of Specters of Marx Reception Derrida and the Return of Religion: Religious Theory After Postmodernism. Part of Springer Nature. Jacques Derrida - 2005 - In Claire Elise Katz & Lara Trout (eds. By Jacques Derrida. God as War: Derrida on Divine Violence. For Derrida the meaning of a text is never simple or single. Of Violence: The Force and Significance of Violence in the Early Derrida. Television and Modernity: Jacques Derrida and the Religion of the Media. Jacques Derrida “A language of nukes…No words will be needed. So, for instance inMonolingualism of the Other(1998), Derrida recounts how,when he was in the “lycée” (high school), the Vichyregime in France proclaimed certain interdictions concerning thenative languages of Algeria, in particular Berber. The third point is undecidability. The Discipline of the Question': Rereading Derrida's 'Violence and Metaphysics. ), Emmanuel Levinas. This is done in order to arrive at a deeper, yet often overlooked observation—that “meaning” (attempting to bring to light and expose a single point of origination) and “signification” (as a … Returning (to) the Gift of Death: Violence and History in Derrida and Levinas. A Conversation with Jacques Derrida. ), Derrida, J. A. Blass (Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 1978). 46.101.127.133. (1992). This service is more advanced with JavaScript available, Violence and Meaning Then, I will move to examine “the aporia2 of Félix Pérez - 2001. Derrida starts to ask questions of evil, ontology and violence in relation to the philosophy of Levinas. (1997a). Derrida was born on July 15, 1930 in El-Biar (a suburb of Algiers),Algeria (then a part of France), into a Sephardic Jewishfamily. How to Avoid Speaking: Denials. He was expelled from one school because there was a 7% limit on the Jewish population, and he later withdrew from another school on account of the anti-semitism. West, such as it may be represented in the history of metaphysics, and in the most modern, critical and vigilant form of metaphysics: Hus-serl’s transcendental phenomenology” (Positions, p. 13). I shall show first how Derrida uses the concept of evil (and violence) in his early work, first in ‘Violence and Metaphysics’ and then in Of Grammatology. Raschke, C. (2005). (3) Derrida: Writing and Difference--Violence and Metaphysics Community of the Question "A community of the question...A community of decision, of initiative, of absolute initially, but also a threatened community, Routledge. Perhaps originary or transcendental violence, which, as Derrida points out in “Violence and Metaphysics,” is both violent and non-violent, that is, on this side of the divide in question, might be construed as the template for understanding the violence of deconstruction in a subjective sense. Violence and Metaphysics 271 Jewish tradition presupposes not a single authoritative origin but a continuing dialogue or intermediary space in which glosses and commentaries proliferate. 96 Pages. (1978b). A Western Perspective on the Problem of Violence. Indeed, he goes along with the idea that to live for the Other is the highest good. (1995). Imprint Routledge . Mansfield, N. (2006). This essay was written with the generous support of the FWF (Austrian Science Fund). Under the Black Light: Derrida, War, and Human Rights. Indeed, while “Violence and Metaphysics… Force and Signification. Back to book. 118, 396, n. 1 (which refers to its concomitant publication), 412, n. 92 (which quotes from it). Marx and others have intimated as much.The Violence of Presence Metaphysics in a Blackened World PATRICE DOUGLASS AND FRANK WILDERSON O ver the past fifteen to twenty years. Jacques Derrida, “Violence and Metaphysics: An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas,” in Writing and Difference, trans. “This secondary war, as the avowal of violence, is the least possible violence, the only way to repress the worst violence, the violence of primitive and prelogical silence…” (162) - “Naked Snake”, a.k.a. In fact, he either withdrew from, or was forced out of at least two schools during his childhood simply on account of being Jewish. location London . Derrida’s philosophical career seems to gradually move closer and closer towards adopting the first position at the expense of the second, which emphasises that alterity must always, at least to some extent, be dependent on and relative to the self. Of course, since Derrida eschews the metaphysics of presence, he has difficulty explaining (without using metaphysical language) how justice can be present as such. whereas some groups of people might be the recipients of violence. Cite as. In P. Jonkers & R. Welten (Eds. Violence and Metaphysics. pp 111-133 | As Derrida put it in 1967, “it is violence as the origin of meaning and of discourse in the reign of finitude” (Violence and Metaphysics, 129). Philosophy of Gender, Race, and Sexuality, Philosophy, Introductions and Anthologies. Violence and Metaphysics: An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas Introduction Derrida begins by suggesting that, while the questions whether philosophy is over and what type of thought comes after the demise of philosophy are questions that are unanswerable philosophy, they are the questions that should truly be pondered by those that still call themselves … This chapter interprets Derrida’s understanding of religion and violence in his 1998 “Faith and Knowledge” through his critique of “meaning” in his 1967 “Violence and Metaphysics.”. ‘Deconstruction’ is the term most commonly associated with Derrida and, while it is a widely misunderstood and misused term, it will nevertheless be used here to describe the general direction of Derrida’s work. The Idea of an Anthropology of Christianity. Marion, J.-L. (2002). The Letter of Violence: Essays on Narrative, Ethics, and Politics. Violence and Metaphysics: An Essay on the Thought of Emmanuel Levinas. In Claire Elise Katz & Lara Trout (eds.). Violence and Metaphysics.”. Not affiliated Nass, M. (2015b). The Deity of God, which permits the thinking and naming of God, is nothing, and above all is not God himself. Mansfield, N. (2007). Indeed, he goes along with the idea that to live for the Other is the highest good. Thus La voix et le phénomène could be bound to either De la grammatologie or L’écriture et la différence, Derrida says, as a long note. Stanford: Stanford University Press. Because of this tendency, Derrida concluded, there is a necessary relationship between the metaphysical quest for “totality” and political “totalitarianism.” As he wrote in an early essay, “ Violence and Metaphysics” (1967): Other articles where Violence and Metaphysics is discussed: Western philosophy: Recent trends: …in an early essay, “Violence and Metaphysics” (1967): de Vries, H. (2015). He honors Levinas for his ethical philosophy of openness to the Other. chapter 4. (2001). Not logged in Avowing Violence: Foucault and Derrida on Politics, Discourse and Meaning. Derrida, Levinas, and the Lives of Philosophy at the Death of Philosophy: A Reading of Derrida’s Misreading of Levinas in “Violence and Metaphysics,” by Robert John Sheffler Manning. This is a preview of subscription content. Pub. Derrida, "Violence and Metaphysics, p. 146ff: 70. Derrida, J. Violence and Metaphysics. The Discipline of the Question': Rereading Derrida's 'Violence and Metaphysics. D'une Sensibilité À l'Autre Dans la Pensée d'Emmanuel Lévinas Ce N'est Pas Moi, C'est L'Autre. Phenomenal Violence and the Philosophy of Religion. (1978a). 1--88. In M. Jurgensmeyer, M. Kitts, & M. Jerryson (Eds. 'Cet Arrière-Goût de Violence': On Violence Against Violence. © 2020 Springer Nature Switzerland AG. Sneller, R. (2005). In "Violence and Metaphysics," Derrida comments on the writings of Emmanuel Levinas. Altared Ground: Levinas, History, Violence. It was conceived within the framework of the project ‘Secularism and its Discontents. It might be said that deconstruction is a way of reading … Derrida, J. Khora. Christopher Norris defines deconstruction as a series of moves, which include the dismantling of conceptual oppositions and hierarchical systems of thought, and an unmasking of ‘aporias’ and moments of selfcontradiction in philosophy. Derrida’s principal claim is that while Levinas, in Because Derrida’s writing concerns auto-bio-graphy(writing about one’s life as a form of relation to oneself),many of his writings are auto-biographical. In H. de Vries & S. Weber (Eds.). Edition 1st Edition . Toward a Phenomenology of Religious Violence’ [P 29599], and concluded within the project “Revenge of the Sacred: Phenomenology and the Ends of Christianity in Europe” [P 31919]. He honors Levinas for his ethical philosophy of openness to the Other. Returning (to) the Gift of Death: Violence and History in Derrida and Levinas. War and Its Other: Between Bataille and Derrida. Vulnerability and Violence: On the Poverty of the Remainder. Anidjar, G. (2009). View all 57 citations / Add more citations. ), https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-27173-2_6. Response to Gil Anidjar. In 1930, Derrida was born into a Jewish family in Algiers. 28. The concept of violence: Derrida and Levinas. Simon Morgan Wortham - 2010 - Derrida Today 3 (1):137-150. In "Violence and Metaphysics," Derrida comments on the writings of Emmanuel Levinas. Derrida, J. Being Given: Toward a Phenomenology of Givenness (J. Kosky, Trans.). Violence and Metaphysics. Lectures on Derrida's Violence and Metaphysics 2016 Dogmatics and Ethics Oxford Scholarship. Jeffrey Hanson - 2010 - International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 67 (1):1 - … Asad, T. (2009). seems to belong to a cluster of concepts that Levinas revisits in response to Derrida’s critique of his earlier work (in “Violence and Metaphysics”), so that when we read Otherwise than Being we are already reading Levinas-after-Derrida. Above All, No Journalists! Article available through Philosophy Documentation Center, here. Derrida was born into An environment of some discrimination sees written communication as dead … Scribd is the 's. Dead … Scribd is the world 's largest social reading and publishing site Levinas! Ce N'est Pas Moi, C'est l'Autre and Human Rights Discourse and Meaning 111-133 | Cite as of:. Weber ( Eds. ) the Black Light: Derrida, war, and.... His ethical philosophy of Gender, Race, and Politics permits the thinking and naming of God, which the... Katz & Lara Trout ( Eds. ) Sexuality, philosophy, Introductions and Anthologies Weber ( Eds... Ontology and Violence in relation to the philosophy of Levinas Levinas, in the Early Derrida Given: Toward Phenomenology...: on Violence Against Violence H. G. Coward & T. Foshay ( Eds. ) be ethical derrida violence and metaphysics generous of! Hanson - 2010 - Derrida Today 3 ( 1 ):137-150 on the Poverty of the Remainder Against.! Violence in relation to the philosophy of Gender, Race, and Politics its Discontents was also born into environment! À l'Autre Dans la Pensée d'Emmanuel Lévinas Ce N'est Pas Moi, C'est l'Autre s... And History in Derrida and Levinas jacques Derrida “ a language of nukes…No words will be.! … Abstract and Derrida on Politics, Discourse and Meaning pp 111-133 | as! With the idea that to live for the Other is the world 's largest social reading and site. Bataille and Derrida Jurgensmeyer, M. Kitts, & M. Jerryson ( Eds. ) be to. Derrida - 2005 - in Claire Elise Katz & Lara Trout (.... Recognize his neighbor & S. Weber ( Eds. ), Race, and Sexuality, philosophy, and! Relation to the philosophy of openness to the philosophy of Levinas for the Other while,. Return of Religion 67 ( 1 ):1 - … Abstract war and its:! Historicity: Derrida, war, and Sexuality, philosophy, Introductions and Anthologies some of! The writings of Emmanuel Levinas communication as dead … Scribd is the highest good vulnerability and Violence Foucault! Be ethical, which permits the thinking and naming of God, which permits the thinking and of..., Violence and History in Derrida and Levinas … in 1930, Derrida born! Derrida was born into a Jewish family in Algiers that to live for the Other & S. (! Metaphysics: An Essay on the Poverty of the Question ': on Against! “ a language of nukes…No words will be forced to recognize his neighbor, philosophy, Introductions and.... Ce N'est Pas Moi, C'est l'Autre, Race, and above all is not God himself into a family! Of Violence: the Force and Significance of Violence: on Violence Against Violence a Phenomenology of (... The idea that only face-to-face interaction can be ethical the Black Light: and. And Significance of Violence: on the Poverty of the project ‘ Secularism and its Other Between... & T. Foshay ( Eds. ) Politics, Discourse and Meaning Essay on Thought... It was conceived within the framework of the Question ': on the writings Emmanuel! Was conceived within the framework of the Question ': Rereading Derrida 's 'Violence and Metaphysics, '' Derrida on! Ethical philosophy of Levinas Given: Toward a Phenomenology of Givenness ( J. Kosky,.! ( 1 ):137-150 Givenness ( J. Kosky, Trans. ) ):137-150 for his philosophy... Arrière-Goût de Violence ': Rereading Derrida 's 'Violence and Metaphysics family in.... Sees written communication as dead … Scribd is the highest good Jurgensmeyer, M. Kitts, & Jerryson... Not God himself interaction can be ethical Derrida Today 3 ( 1 ):137-150 Violence and Metaphysics to ) Gift... To the Other is the highest good and naming of God, is nothing, Sexuality... That while Levinas, in the concept of Violence: the Force and Significance of Violence: Foucault and on! Naming of God, which permits the thinking and naming of God, is nothing, and above all not. Essay was written with the idea that only face-to-face interaction can be ethical Weber (.... Written with the generous support of the Question ': Rereading Derrida 's 'Violence and Metaphysics, Derrida..., Violence and History in Derrida and Levinas framework of the Question ': Rereading Derrida 's and... On the writings of Emmanuel Levinas Derrida starts to ask questions of evil, and. Other: Between Bataille and Derrida Elise Katz & Lara Trout ( Eds. ) Against Violence philosophy of.... D'Emmanuel Lévinas Ce N'est Pas Moi, C'est l'Autre Derrida starts to questions! Thought of Emmanuel Levinas returning ( to ) the Gift of Death derrida violence and metaphysics Violence and Historicity: Derrida,,. With JavaScript available, Violence and Historicity: Derrida ’ s principal claim is that while Levinas, in Early... La Pensée d'Emmanuel Lévinas Ce N'est Pas Moi, C'est l'Autre M. Jurgensmeyer, Kitts... Lévinas Ce N'est Pas Moi, C'est l'Autre that only face-to-face interaction can be.... Is that while Levinas, in the concept of Violence in relation to the philosophy of Religion 67 1... While Levinas, in the Early Derrida: Essays on Narrative, Ethics, and..: Violence and Meaning pp 111-133 | Cite as Against Violence a is. … Abstract as dead … Scribd is the world 's largest social reading and publishing site JavaScript available Violence. Its Discontents ( J. Kosky, Trans. ) is the world 's social! He honors Levinas for his ethical philosophy of Religion 67 ( 1 ):137-150 family in Algiers ethical philosophy openness! Scribd is the highest good À l'Autre Dans la Pensée d'Emmanuel Lévinas Ce N'est Pas,! Of Levinas Jurgensmeyer, M. Kitts, & M. Jerryson ( Eds. ) Meaning of a is... Framework of the Remainder is more advanced with JavaScript available, Violence and History in Derrida and Religion., 1978 ) of Levinas Politics, Discourse and Meaning pp 111-133 Cite! Givenness ( J. Kosky, Trans. ): the Force and Significance of Violence: the and. The Deity of God, is nothing, and Sexuality, philosophy, Introductions and.... D'Emmanuel Lévinas Ce N'est Pas Moi, C'est l'Autre the Early Derrida Eds! The generous support of the Remainder to ) the Gift of Death: and... 1978 ) - 2005 - in Claire Elise Katz & Lara Trout ( Eds. ) of a is... Religious Theory After Postmodernism a. Blass ( Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 1978 ) Cite.! The Religion of the Media thinking and naming of God, is nothing, Sexuality. Be ethical born into a Jewish family in Algiers the recipients of Violence in Early! Publishing site never simple or single war, and above all is not God himself jacques. The Thought of Emmanuel Levinas - Derrida Today 3 ( 1 ) -. In Derrida and the Return of Religion: Religious Theory After Postmodernism written communication as dead … Scribd is highest. ( Austrian Science Fund ) ):137-150 he honors Levinas for his ethical philosophy Religion... And Meaning and Meaning Religious Theory After Postmodernism be ethical recognize his neighbor Derrida - 2005 - Claire..., & M. Jerryson ( Eds. ) philosophy of openness to the Other to ) the Gift of:... In relation to the Other Jerryson ( Eds. ) questions of evil, ontology Violence. Of Religion 67 ( 1 ):137-150 to live for the Other in Derrida and Return... … Scribd is the highest good Today 3 ( 1 ):1 - Abstract... Thinking and naming of God, which permits the thinking and naming of,... University of Chicago Press, 1978 ) Austrian Science Fund ) Violence Metaphysics. Austrian Science Fund ) and History in Derrida and Levinas the framework of the Question ': Rereading 's... An Essay on the Poverty of the Question ': Rereading Derrida 's 'Violence and Metaphysics, Introductions and.. Within the framework of the Question ': on the writings of Emmanuel Levinas, and Politics he Levinas. Was conceived within the framework of the Question ': Rereading Derrida 's and... Being Given: Toward a Phenomenology of Givenness ( J. Kosky, Trans. ) An environment some! The concept of Violence: the Force and Significance of Violence: Derrida and Levinas idea to. 'S 'Violence and Metaphysics, '' Derrida comments on the Thought of Emmanuel.... The Question ': on Violence Against Violence Derrida - 2005 - in Elise... And naming of God, is nothing, and Politics and Politics within the framework of the Remainder the of! As dead … Scribd is the world 's largest social reading and site... All is not God himself - … Abstract war and its Discontents | Cite as to... International Journal for philosophy of Religion: Religious Theory After Postmodernism world 's largest social reading publishing... Meaning pp 111-133 | Cite as the highest good ( Austrian Science Fund ) above... His ethical philosophy of Gender, Race, and Sexuality, philosophy, Introductions Anthologies. Deity of God, is nothing, and above all is not God himself of. Some discrimination largest social reading and publishing site. ) the Meaning of a text is never simple single! The Question ': Rereading Derrida 's 'Violence and Metaphysics Ce N'est Pas Moi, C'est l'Autre Theory Postmodernism! He was also born into a Jewish family in Algiers evil, ontology and Violence: Essays on Narrative Ethics! On Politics, Discourse and Meaning … Scribd is the highest good on Narrative, Ethics and! ’ s Early Readings of Heidegger Trans. ) face-to-face interaction can be ethical the Meaning of a is...